Perfumes Similar to Versace Eros

Versace Eros is one of the best-selling men’s fragrances of the last decade, and its sweet, fresh mix of mint, green apple, vanilla, and tonka bean is instantly recognizable. If you love that DNA but want the same vibe for less, or you simply want a fresh take on it, these perfumes similar to Versace Eros are the closest matches we could verify on Amazon US.

We compared seven perfumes similar to Versace Eros side by side, from the official flanker to the closest clone, and every pick below links to a verified Amazon US listing. Here is the short version: English Laundry Oxford Bleu is the closest match, Eros Flame is the warmest official option, and Guess 1981 Los Angeles is the best budget buy.

The Best Perfumes Similar to Versace Eros at a Glance

Use this table to compare all seven picks at a glance. Every one of these perfumes similar to Versace Eros links to a verified Amazon US listing, so you can check the current price in one click.

#ProductPickBest ForCheck Price
1
Versace Eros EDP
Versace Eros EDP
Eau de Parfum
Editor’s PickBest overallCheck Price
2
English Laundry Oxford Bleu EDP
English Laundry Oxford Bleu EDP
Eau de Parfum
Closest matchCheck Price
3
Versace Eros Flame EDP
Versace Eros Flame EDP
Eau de Parfum
Warm, spicy flankerCheck Price
4
Guess 1981 Los Angeles EDT
Guess 1981 Los Angeles EDT
Eau de Toilette
Best budget pickCheck Price
5
Natura Homem Sagaz EDT
Natura Homem Sagaz EDT
Eau de Toilette
Best cloneCheck Price
6
Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male In The Navy EDT
Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male In The Navy EDT
Eau de Toilette
Best designer alternativeCheck Price
7
Mandarina Duck Black EDT
Mandarina Duck Black EDT
Eau de Toilette
Best cheap dupeCheck Price

A quick note on how we chose these seven. We started from the clone lists published by FragranceReview and Best Men’s Colognes, then kept only the scents with a verified, exact Amazon US listing. A few popular designer options were left out because we could not verify an exact Amazon US listing for the exact bottle, and we link the original Mandarina Duck Black, not the discontinued Black Extreme.

1. Versace Eros EDP — The Benchmark

Every perfumes similar to Versace Eros list starts here, because Eros is the benchmark all the others are measured against. The original 2012 eau de parfum blends cool mint and green apple over a warm base of vanilla and tonka bean, with cedarwood giving it structure. It is sweet, fresh, and loud in the best way.

Eros is also the longest-lasting pick in this guide. As an eau de parfum, it projects for hours and holds up through a full evening out, which is why it remains a go-to date-night and club scent. If you are new to the strength, read our guide to what eau de parfum means before you buy.

Buy Eros itself if you want the real thing and the best performance in this list. Buy one of the alternatives below if you want the same DNA for less money, or a slightly different spin on the same idea.

2. English Laundry Oxford Bleu EDP — The Closest Match

Of all the perfumes similar to Versace Eros we compared, Oxford Bleu comes closest to the original. Reviewers call it probably the closest thing to Eros on the market, and wearing them side by side makes the comparison easy to understand: the same cool mint and apple opening, the same sweet vanilla and tonka bean dry down.

Oxford Bleu is an eau de parfum, so it lasts longer than most of the budget alternatives in this guide. It smells a touch more polished and less loud than Eros, which makes it the easiest everyday wear of the bunch. If you want one bottle that could replace Eros in your rotation, this is it.

The trade-off is availability: Oxford Bleu is a smaller brand, so it is not always in stock in every size. When it is available, it is usually the best value per wear of any Eros alternative.

3. Versace Eros Flame EDP — The Official Flanker

Eros Flame is the official flanker, so it belongs on any list of perfumes similar to Versace Eros. Versace kept the sweet vanilla and tonka bean heart of Eros and turned up the heat with chili pepper and rosemary, giving it a warmer, spicier character that works best in cool weather and evening wear.

Think of it as Eros after dark. The opening is brighter and more peppery, the dry down is richer, and the red bottle is a good visual cue for the change in mood. It is still unmistakably Eros DNA, just with the volume turned toward warmth instead of freshness.

If you already own Eros and want a second bottle for winter, Eros Flame is the obvious next buy. We compared the two in detail in our Versace Eros vs Eros Flame guide.

4. Guess 1981 Los Angeles EDT — The Best Budget Pick

Guess 1981 Los Angeles is the best budget buy among the perfumes similar to Versace Eros in this guide. It opens fresh and fruity, then settles into a sweet, tonka bean-based base that echoes Eros at a fraction of the price. The amber bottle and sunset box look far more expensive than the scent costs.

Performance is the compromise. As an eau de toilette, it does not last as long as Eros or Oxford Bleu, so plan on a midday refresh if you wear it to work. For the price, though, it is hard to beat: this is the bottle to grab when you want the Eros vibe without thinking about the cost.

It also makes a great first cologne. The scent is friendly, crowd-pleasing, and hard to overspray badly, which is exactly what a beginner needs.

5. Natura Homem Sagaz EDT — The Best Clone

Homem Sagaz is the most faithful clone among the perfumes similar to Versace Eros here. Reviewers describe it as an Eros clone with a vanilla and apple top, and that is exactly how it wears: sweet, fresh, and very close to the original in the first hour.

Natura is a Brazilian brand, so Sagaz is less familiar to US buyers than the designer names in this list. That is part of its charm. The red bottle stands out on a shelf, and the scent itself is smooth and well-blended rather than a rough copy.

Choose Sagaz if you want the closest possible match to Eros and do not mind ordering a lesser-known brand. It is the pick for collectors who have tried the usual suspects and want something different.

6. Jean Paul Gaultier Le Male In The Navy EDT — The Best Designer Alternative

Le Male In The Navy is the most designer-polished of the perfumes similar to Versace Eros in this guide. It takes the familiar Le Male lavender and vanilla base and adds a fresh mint opening that is clearly reminiscent of Eros, then keeps the whole thing sweet and creamy.

This is the safest designer pick on the list. Jean Paul Gaultier’s quality control is excellent, the striped sailor bottle is iconic, and the scent works in almost any setting, from the office to a night out.

The trade-off is similarity: In The Navy is Eros-adjacent rather than an Eros twin. If you want the closest match, pick Oxford Bleu or Sagaz. If you want a designer scent with Eros energy, this is the one.

7. Mandarina Duck Black EDT — The Best Cheap Dupe

Mandarina Duck Black is the sleeper pick among the perfumes similar to Versace Eros we tested. Reviewers call it very similar to Eros, with vanilla and tonka bean notes that make it sweet and creamy in exactly the way Eros is.

It is also one of the oldest scents on this list, which is a compliment: it has been quietly doing the Eros job since long before Eros existed. The matte black bottle is understated, and the scent is smooth, warm, and easy to wear every day.

One warning: shop carefully. The brand has released several Black flankers, including a discontinued Black Extreme. We link the original Mandarina Duck Black here, which is the version reviewers compare to Eros.

How to Choose the Best Perfume Similar to Versace Eros for You

Choosing among perfumes similar to Versace Eros comes down to three things: how close you want the match, how much you want to spend, and when you will wear it. Here is how to weigh each one.

Match the DNA, Not Just the Name

The Eros DNA is mint, apple, vanilla, and tonka bean. Oxford Bleu and Homem Sagaz copy that recipe most faithfully, while Le Male In The Navy and Eros Flame keep the sweetness but change the character. If you want people to ask whether you are wearing Eros, pick the closest match. If you want your own scent with Eros energy, pick the designer spin.

Always test on skin before you commit to a full bottle. Paper strips lie, especially with sweet scents, and tonka bean can turn powdery or cloying depending on your skin chemistry.

Decide Your Budget First

Eros itself and Eros Flame sit at designer prices, while Guess 1981 and Mandarina Duck Black cost a fraction of that. The middle ground is Oxford Bleu and Le Male In The Navy, which feel premium without the premium price. Set your budget before you fall in love with a bottle.

Remember that concentration matters too. An eau de parfum usually costs more per milliliter than an eau de toilette, but it also lasts longer, so the cost per wear can be similar. For more on the house, see our best Versace perfumes guide.

Pick for the Season and the Occasion

Eros and its closest matches shine in spring and summer, when the mint and apple feel fresh. Eros Flame and Le Male In The Navy are the better cold-weather picks, thanks to their warmer spice. For the office, choose the lighter options, Oxford Bleu or Guess 1981. For date night, reach for Eros or Eros Flame.

If you can only buy one bottle, make it the one that fits the season you are in now. You can always add a second match later.

Top 3 Editor’s Picks

These are the three perfumes similar to Versace Eros we would buy first. The original for the best performance, Oxford Bleu for the closest match, and Eros Flame for the warmest official take.

1. Versace Eros EDP

Versace Eros EDP

The benchmark. The sweetest, freshest, longest-lasting scent in this guide, and still the one to beat.

2. English Laundry Oxford Bleu EDP

English Laundry Oxford Bleu EDP

The closest match. Probably the nearest thing to Eros on the market, with better everyday wearability.

3. Versace Eros Flame EDP

Versace Eros Flame EDP

The warmest official take. Chili pepper and rosemary over the familiar vanilla and tonka bean heart.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What are the best perfumes similar to Versace Eros?
English Laundry Oxford Bleu is the closest match, followed by Natura Homem Sagaz and Mandarina Duck Black. If you want the official version, Versace Eros Flame is the flanker built on the same DNA.

Which cologne smells exactly like Versace Eros?
Nothing smells exactly like Eros, but Oxford Bleu comes closest in blind comparisons. Homem Sagaz is a close second. Both share the mint, apple, vanilla, and tonka bean structure that defines Eros.

Is Eros Flame the same as Eros?
No. Eros Flame is a flanker, not a reissue. It keeps the vanilla and tonka bean heart but adds chili pepper and rosemary for a warmer, spicier character. Eros is fresher; Eros Flame is warmer.

Are perfumes similar to Versace Eros cheaper than Eros?
Most of them are. Guess 1981 Los Angeles and Mandarina Duck Black cost a fraction of Eros, while Oxford Bleu and Le Male In The Navy sit in the middle. Eros itself is the most expensive pick in this guide.

What is the best cheap dupe for Versace Eros?
Mandarina Duck Black is our pick for the best cheap dupe, with Guess 1981 Los Angeles close behind. Both are sweet, creamy, and built on the same vanilla and tonka bean base as Eros.

Where can I buy these Eros alternatives?
Every pick in this guide links to a verified Amazon US listing. We also rounded up more options in our Eros EDP alternatives guide.

The Bottom Line: Our Verdict on Perfumes Similar to Versace Eros

If you want the real thing, buy Eros. If you want the same sweet, fresh DNA for less, the perfumes similar to Versace Eros above give you seven proven options. Oxford Bleu is the closest match, Eros Flame is the best official alternative, and Guess 1981 is the smartest budget buy.

Start with one bottle, wear it for a week, and see how it performs on your skin. The best Eros alternative is the one you reach for every morning, not the one that wins a paper-strip comparison.

Leave a Comment